Although cute, babies can produce some foul smelling diapers. To keep your nursery smelling clean and fresh, get a diaper pail that locks in odors and makes clean up a bit easier.
Unfortunately, there are a lot of bad diaper pails on the market.
To ensure that the diaper pail you get does a great job locking in odors, we analyzed 26 product and 729 consumer reviews over a process of 28 hours.
Although there are quite a few good options, our favorite is the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System because it provides a hands-free experience and clean smelling nursery.
Diaper Pail Comparative Table
|Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System||
||9.0/10||See price on Amazon|
|Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail||
||9.2/10||See price on Amazon|
|Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail||
||8.8/10||See price on Amazon|
Our Pick for The Best Diaper Pail
The Best Overall
Our top pick for the best diaper pail in Canada in 2023 is the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System. It provides some of the best odor blocking features and technology without breaking the budget. Unfortunately, there are quality control issues to note.
Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System Video Review
What We Think of The Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System
The Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System is the best overall diaper pail on the market, and we’re not the only ones who think so. This is a top selling diaper pail with over 1,000,000 parents opting for this pail specifically.
The reason why so many parents love the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System is because it is an all-in-one diaper pail. It is hands free and comes with double clamps for ease of use and convenience. For further convenience, it has a tall height so that you don’t even have to bend over to toss away The dirty diapers.
Smell is no match for this pail either. It comes with a carbon filter to help lock in odors and absorb any odors that may be trying to seep out. Its smell busting design is one of the most effective on the market.
On top of these fantastic features, this diaper pail system is still affordable. When compared to the other diaper pails on this list, this product falls right in the middle, making it reasonable enough for most families.
I’ve used this for my baby and my pets. Looks cheap and flimsy, but it keeps the odor concealed. Since I can’t find any better odor prevention options, I am sticking to this!
If you get a Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System that works as it should, cleaning up after your baby’s messes will be a breeze, but there are quality control issues with this product. Although many parents love it, other users report that it breaks easy and has a cheap construction.
Users that note these drawbacks claim that this is still the best product in terms of odor prevention. For this reason, the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System is the best overall diaper pail since it blocks odors so effectively. Just know that it’s a bit flimsy looking and not as durable as some of the other models.
Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System Specifications
- Brand: Playtex
- Dimensions: 68.58 x 30.63 x 23.81 cm
- Weight: 3.62 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Tall height, foot pedal, odor control, two clamps
Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System Pros and Cons
- Tall height reduces work
- Phenomenal odor blockage
- Affordable price
- Flimsy looking
- Breaks easily
Our Final Opinion about the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System
Quality 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.2 Effectiveness 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.7 Design 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.3 Price 4.5 out of 5.0 stars
We recommend the Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System to any parent who is looking to conceal the diaper odor. Even though is a bit flimsy, it is hands down the best for odor prevention and convenience.
Our Upgrade Pick for a Diaper Pail
The High Performance Pick
If you need a high performing baby diaper pail, we recommend the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail. Although highly expensive, this pail offers some of the most impressive durability and odor logging prevention, and it doesn’t even require special bags.
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail Video Review
What We Think of The Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail
If you intend to have more children in the future, you might want to get a diaper pail that is highly durable and long lasting so that you don’t have to buy a new pail when the next baby comes. Our favorite high performing pail is the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail.
Unlike most other diaper pails, this model is made from powder coated steel. This steel makes the product highly durable and prevents odors from locking onto the pail. Because of its durability and odor wicking material, you can expect this diaper pail to last you a long time.
To ensure that no odors seep into your room either, the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail includes rubber seals that ensure none of the diaper odors seep through the top of the pail.
There are some other impressive features about the pail. For example, it does not require a special bag, it comes with a bag holder that avoids bag breakage, and it features a childproof safety lock. These features create a safe and efficient pail that you can count on for years.
Plus, this pail comes in eight color options. This is one of the few diaper pails that comes with this many stylistic choices. No matter what style your nursery has, you should be able to find a Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail to match.
As you would expect from a high performance pick, the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail is highly expensive. It is not the most expensive product on our list, but it is more than twice the price of our best overall pail.
I love the bin. It is super economical. I use it with twins and a 35 liter bag. I only have to change it every two to three days. There’s only a hint of a smell whenever the bin is open. I love this and would recommend!
In addition to the high price, there are complaints about the pail rusting after some time. This rust is a serious downside, especially if you want your pail to last many years. There are a few complaints that it doesn’t trap in odor well, but these complaints are few in number.
Even with these complaints in mind, the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail is our high performance pick. It is made from powder coated steel that creates a durable, fashionable, and effective pail for your child’s nursery.
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail Specifications
- Brand: Ubbi
- Dimensions: 38.1 x 27.3 x 57.1 cm
- Weight: 3.18 kg
- Color: Several options
- Special Features: Rubber locks, powder coated steel, covered rim, childproof safety lock
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail Pros and Cons
- Made from steel
- Highly durable
- Comes in many color choices
- Effective odor prevention
- May rust
Our Final Opinion About the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail
Quality 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.7 Effectiveness 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.8 Design 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.9 Price:4.1]
We recommend the Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail for individuals who want a high performance diaper pail that is durable, attractive, and efficient. Although it is expensive and may rust, it is the best pail in terms of performance.
Our Budget Pick for a Diaper Pail
The Budget Pick
The Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail is our value pick because it is highly affordable, does not absorb odor, and keeps odor under control. The main drawback is that it is very small and is best suited as a secondary diaper pail.
Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail Video Review
What We Think of the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail
Let’s face it: babies are a fortune, and most parents don’t have hundreds of dollars to splurge on the most expensive diaper pail out there. If you are looking to save some money while still getting an effective diaper pail, we recommend the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail.
Based on price alone, this diaper pail is fairly affordable. In fact, it is the most affordable model on our list. It is cheap enough that it should be suited for nearly any budget, no matter how small the budget may be.
All the while, the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail works very well. It has triple odor control to keep the nasty smell inside the pail. Furthermore, it is made from closed cell plastic to prevent the plastic from absorbing odors from the diaper.
To further increase the value of this diaper pail, you can easily convert the pail into a regular trash can after your child is potty trained. That way, you can still get your money’s worth from this product, long after you no longer need an option for diapers.
One thing to be aware of before purchasing this model is that it is very small. It is a mini diaper pail that is specifically designed as a secondary pail. As a result, you will have to dump out this pail frequently if you use it as your primary option.
I have a larger one in my bedroom and this model in my living room. It’s clean looking and fits into my modern decor without drawing much attention to it. I recommend this for rooms that you don’t expect making many diaper changes in.
There are also some complaints about it being difficult to find refills for the pail. This complaint surprised us because we could easily find refill bags. Perhaps the bag refills get sold out frequently.
Nevertheless, the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail is a great find for parents on a budget. It is effective and can even convert into a trash can, but it is incredibly small.
Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail Specifications
- Brand: Dekor
- Dimensions: 17.78 x 17.78 x 25.4 cm
- Weight: 1.69 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Foot pedal, triple level odor protection, converts into a garbage bin
Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail Pros and Cons
- Highly affordable
- Converts into a garbage bin
- Does not absorb smell
Our Final Opinion About the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail
Quality 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Effectiveness 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.6 Design 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.6 Price 5.0 out of 5.0 stars
Because if its price and garbage bin conversion design, the Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail is a great product if you are on a budget. We specifically recommend this to parents who need a budget pail and who don’t mind cleaning out the pail frequently.
Alternative Products to Consider
Skip Hop Diaper Pail Review
The Slim Space Pick
The Skip Hop Diaper Pail is designed with a streamlined and space-saving design for tight spaces. It even comes with a built-in storage compartment for further convenience, but it is expensive.
Skip Hop Diaper Pail Video Review
What We Think of the Skip Hop Diaper Pail
If you don’t have a lot of room to dedicate to a large diaper pail, we recommend the Skip Hop Diaper Pail. This diaper pail is specifically designed for tight spaces because of its tall and slim design. You can easily fit this pail next to your changing station or other trash cans without taking up too much space.
To save more space, the Skip Hop Diaper Pail comes with a built-in storage compartment. This storage compartment can keep your essentials neatly stacked up next to the other diaper changing features in your nursery.
You can also count on the Skip Hop Diaper Pail to keep odors within the trash can. It comes with a dual airlock disposal system so that all odors are trapped inside the odor resistant stainless steel bin. Some other features that this diaper pail has includes easy clean surfaces, childproof lock, and standard trash bag size.
Even though the Skip Hop Diaper Pail saves space in your home, it certainly does not save any cash. This model is pretty expensive. Those on a budget will likely want to opt for a different compact design.
I’m happy I got this recommendation and followed it. I recommend this to mothers who want a pail with an extra nice look and for mothers who are willing to pay a little bit extra for a nice bin.
On top of the expensive price, there are quality control issues of this model. Several users note that the lid does not stay closed very well, which allows odors to seep out when you least want them to. Because of how expensive this product is, it should be more effective at odor control.
Overall, the Skip Hop Diaper Pail has a unique design that makes it suitable for homes tight on space. Even though there are some notable drawbacks, it might be the right pick for apartments and small nurseries.
Skip Hop Diaper Pail Specifications
- Brand: Skip Hop
- Dimensions: 36.83 x 20.96 x 69.22 cm
- Weight: 4.22 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Wipe clean surfaces, dual air lock system, storage compartment on top
Skip Hop Diaper Pail Pros and Cons
- Compact design
- Comes with extra storage
- Easy to clean
- Quality control issues
Our Final Opinion About the Skip Hop Diaper Pail
Quality 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.4 Effectiveness 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Design 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Price:4.1]
The Skip Hop Diaper Pail is a good choice for individuals who are tight on space because of its compact design. Before purchasing this model, we recommend thinking carefully about whether or not you’re willing to risk getting a relatively expensive pail with quality control issues.
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail Review
The Easy Liner Pick
The Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is ideal since you can use it with any standard plastic bag. Many parents appreciate its universal bag design and low price, but it doesn’t offer the best odor protection.
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail Review
What We Think of The Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
The Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is a rather basic diaper pail that is designed to make your life a little bit easier.
One way that it helps out new parents is that you can use any standard plastic bag inside the pail. This means you don’t have to waste your time searching for specific liners that fit. For further convenience, the model has an easy one hand use. Because of this one hand used, you can still hold your baby while throwing away the dirty diaper.
In terms of price, the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is one of the most affordable options on our list. It is only slightly more expensive than our budget pick, making it a great option for parents who are looking to save a little bit of money.
Great product. It has a large capacity for its size and does not require expensive bags. I recommend using an activated charcoal filter to help mask some of the odor.
Unfortunately, there are notable downsides to this model. For example, it is very small, and it does not offer great odor protection. Even though it comes with a deodorizer disc, several parents report that it does a terrible job of concealing the smell.
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail Specifications
- Brand: Safety 1st
- Dimensions: 38.1 x 46.69 x 27.64 cm
- Weight: 1.32 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Single hand use, child safety lock
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail Pros and Cons
- Uses any standard plastic bag
- One hand use
- Easy to use
- Not very large
- Does not trap odors well
Our Final Opinion About the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
Quality 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Effectiveness 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.3 Design 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Price:4.7]
Even though it is nothing fancy, the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail may be the right choice for you if you want a pail that can use just about any bag and doesn’t cost a fortune.
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Review
The Odor Prevention Pick
The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is the perfect option if you have extreme odor that needs to be controlled. Overall, this model offers some of the most impressive diaper pail features, but it is extremely expensive.
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Video Review
What We Think of the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail
Even though all diaper pails claim to prevent odors, not all deliver what they promise, and even the ones that do fail to compete with the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail. This pail is powered by Arm & Hammer to provide the best odor protection possible.
What makes this pail so effective at odor protection is that it has a self-sealing ability that seals the bag every single time the lid closes. For additional odor protection, the pail is backed with a baking soda cartridge to absorb excess odor.
Something that’s unique about this pail is that with every pail purchased, the Munchkin brand plants a tree to offset carbon emissions. Think about how this will benefit your child’s life in the future!
This diaper pail is so impressive that it is actually award-winning. In 2020, Good Housekeeping voted this pail as the best overall diaper pail of the year.
This is as close to perfect as you will get when it comes to concealing diaper smells. It’s also good because we can keep our dogs out of the dirty diapers. I’ve used it for both my children, and it has lasted. As a hack for the expensive bags, we buy knockoffs or make our own.
User after user reports that this is one of the best diaper pails they have ever found. There is practically no common critique launched against this pail. The only complaint we have about this product is its extremely expensive price tag. This is the most expensive diaper pail on our list.
If you are willing to spend any amount of money on the most impressive diaper pail, the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is a good way to spend your money. It offers the best odor protection and even gives a tree to offset gas emissions.
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Specifications
- Brand: Munchkin
- Dimensions: 31.12 x 70.18 x 33.02 cm
- Weight: 5.48 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Arm & Hammer odor prevention, self-sealing system, foot pedal, child safety lock, plant a tree for every pail purchased
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Pros and Cons
- Most effective at odor prevention
- Self-sealing abilities
- Arm & Hammer odor technology
- Highly durable
- Highly expensive
Our Final Opinion About the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail
Quality 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.6 Effectiveness 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.9 Design 4.0 out of 5.0 stars.8 Price:4.0]
We recommend the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail to parents who need extreme odor protection. Because of the Arm & Hammer technology, this pail is the most effective at odor control, but it is expensive.
Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail Review
The Portable Pick
The Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail is our portable pick because it is small, portable, and offers organization for all of your diaper accessories. Because of its portable design, it is not a good choice for everyday use.
Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail Video Review
What We Think of The Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail
If you need a pail that can go with you, we recommend the Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail. This pail is specifically designed like a caddy so that you can carry the pail with you whenever you are on the go.
So that it is convenient to travel with, this caddy is compact, but it can still hold a day’s worth of diapers at a time. For further space-saving features, the caddy even comes with organization trays so that you can keep extra diapers, wipes, and other items on hand.
Price wise, this mini diaper pail is super affordable. It’s about the same price as our budget pick, making it a great product for parents on a budget. All the while, it uses the same diaper genie technology to trap in odor.
Because the Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail is designed for portable use, it makes a terrible everyday option. It simply is not large enough to use as your regular diaper pail, though it may be a great choice to keep in the car.
I love this portable caddy. I’ve been using the full size product for a long time. I was worried about purchasing the mini because several people noted that the lid doesn’t stay closed, but mine works perfectly. I am even bringing it to grandma’s tomorrow.
At the end of the day, the Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail is a good choice for portable use, but you should overlook it if you are looking for a pail to use inside your home on a regular basis.
Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail Specifications
- Brand: Diaper Genie
- Dimensions: 25.4 x 30.48 x 38.1 cm
- Weight: 2.27 kg
- Color: White
- Special Features: Handle, storage compartment, compact
Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail Pros and Cons
- Designed for travel
- Additional storage areas
- Locks away odors on the go
- Not ideal for everyday use
Our Final Opinion About the Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail
Quality 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Effectiveness 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Design 4.5 out of 5.0 stars Price:4.8]
If you need a diaper pail for the go, the Diaper Genie Quick Caddy Mini Portable Diaper Disposal Pail is a great choice because it is affordable and locks in odor while still being compact. Individuals looking for an everyday pail should opt for something larger.
Why Should You Trust Us?
All the recommendations we make on The Good Choice are the result of many hours of research, comparisons, analysis of consumer reviews and, if necessary, expert feedbacks. The products we recommend here are the ones that will best perform their daily tasks, passing all security, reliability and efficiency tests while having an appealing price-quality ratio for everyone.
What are our criteria for judging the products reviewed and selected by The Good Choice?
- Quality: Does the product have a solid construction? Will it be reliable over time? Does it have a good warranty?
- Efficiency: Is the product efficient in its task or do you need to give it some help? Is it for example powerful, fast, quiet?
- Usability: Is the product easy to handle, easy to use and maintain?
- Price: Is the price of the product and/or accessories and/or spare parts reasonable compared to the rest of the market?
In addition to these main criteria, we then establish a list of specific criteria for each product category, detailed a little further down in this article.
In the end, the products we recommend are the ones we would want to buy, and the ones we would also choose for our friends and family.
Things to Know Before Buying a Diaper Pail
Can I just use a regular lidded garbage can for my baby’s diapers?
Even though it may be tempting to use a regular lidded garbage can for your baby’s diapers, you will quickly regret the decision. Garbage cans, even those with lids, are not designed to trap the foul odor from the diaper. Only by opting for a good diaper pail can you minimize the amount of odor seepage from your baby’s dirty diaper.
What’s the difference between a diaper pail and regular garbage can?
Diaper pails are often designed so as to trap the foul odors from the dirty diaper inside the pail. Garbage cans, in comparison, only hold items until you dump them out with the rest of your garbage. Additionally, many diaper pails come with additional features to help minimize odors and protect your children from getting into them, which most garbage cans lack.
Can I use a diaper pail with cloth diapers?
Most people who buy diaper pails use disposable diapers. If you use cloth diapers instead, it is still recommended to use a diaper pail to minimize odors. We recommend getting a stainless steel diaper pail if you use cloth diapers to make cleanup easy.
What type of liner should I get for my diaper pail?
The type of liner you get depends on the type of diapers you use. If you use disposable diapers, opt for plastic liners that can easily be disposed of once the pail is filled up. If you use cloth diapers, you will probably want to use a cloth liner that you can wash with the diapers to minimize odors and make cleanup easy.
How do I clean out my diaper pail?
Always clean out your diaper pail after it fills up. Even if you are diligent in replacing liners, seepage can get onto your diaper pail. Use hot water and a cleaning solution to thoroughly disinfect the pail itself. If your diaper pail is made from plastic, you might want to opt for a deodorizer to ensure that the odor doesn’t stick to the inside of the pail.
How to Properly Choose Your Diaper Pail
Even if you know which diaper pails are impressive and which ones should be tossed away, it still can be difficult to know which diaper pail is right for your home, baby, and needs. So that you bring home the right diaper pail, we have found the five most important factors to consider when choosing your diaper pail.
These factors include material, size, liner type, additional features, and price. By considering these factors, you can narrow down the selection to find the best diaper pail for you.
Diaper pails are always made from stainless steel or plastic. These two materials are chosen because they are the most effective at locking in odors while still being lightweight, portable, easy to clean, and relatively affordable. Both of these materials come with their own advantages and disadvantages:
- Plastic: Plastic is the most affordable and lightweight of the two options, though plastic can start to absorb the odor surrounding it. Opt for plastic if you are on a tight budget, but know you will need to clean it regularly and potentially buy a new pail if it starts smelling.
- Stainless Steel: Stainless steel is the best material outright because it does not absorb odors. As a result, it’s much easier to keep clean. Plus, it looks high class and can fit into any nursery. Its downside is that it is more expensive than plastic.
It is up to you to decide whether you want a plastic or stainless steel pail. We recommend plastic for those on a budget but stainless steel for those who want the most effective option.
Most diaper pails can hold anywhere between 15 and 50 diapers. The average size is capable of holding baby wipes and 35 to 40 diapers. You will want to consider how many diapers you expect to be changing and how frequently you want to change out the pail.
The average newborn goes through more than 10 dirty diapers a day. If you have twins, the number of dirty diapers multiplies. Do the math based on how many babies are in your home. Then, consider how often you are willing to change out the pail to determine pail size.
Just as garbage bins need garbage bags, your diaper pail will need a liner. The most common liner type is plastic liners, such as small garbage bin bags or used grocery bags. These liners are advantageous because they are relatively cheap and can simply be thrown away with the diapers. We recommend plastic liners if you use disposable diapers.
Parents that use reusable diapers will want a cloth liner instead. The cloth liner will be more expensive upfront, but you will reuse it over and over again. Cloth liners are great for reusable diapers because you simply toss the liner in with the diapers.
Note that you don’t technically have to use a liner. Some parents prefer to just use the pail itself to minimize costs. If you do not use a liner, you will have to clean out the pail frequently. We recommend using the liner for this reason.
Diaper pails often come with additional features to make the diaper changing experience at least a little bit more convenient. The most popular features to look for include diaper pail clamps, odor filters, foot pedals, and child safety locks.
The more features a pail comes with, the more expensive it will be. Simply look for the features that you know you will appreciate without making the diaper pail price increase too much.
Babies are expensive. If you have recently brought a child home, you are likely on a tight budget. Luckily, diaper pails come in many price ranges. Simply select the best diaper pail within a range you are comfortable paying. The material and features of the pail will largely determine its price.
We do our best to provide you with a comparative guide of diaper pails allowing you to choose the best product possible. If we are missing information or new models, do not hesitate to leave a comment below or to send us a message.